Journal Publication · Research Guide

How to Respond to Journal Reviewer Comments: Examples and Template

Peer review is a request to strengthen the manuscript’s logic and evidence. A useful response letter shows exactly what changed, where it changed and how the concern was resolved.

By ILM Research Solutions Research TeamPublished ~8 min read

IN BRIEF

Quick answer

Read the editor’s decision carefully, group all reviewer requests, revise the manuscript first, then prepare a respectful point-by-point response quoting or summarizing each comment and citing the revised page, line, figure or supplement.

Read the decision letter before editing

Separate mandatory editorial requests from reviewer suggestions, and check the revision deadline and allowed file formats. Identify whether the decision is major revision, minor revision, resubmission or rejection; requirements differ.

Make a tracking table with reviewer number, comment ID, action required, responsible author, manuscript location and completion status. Resolve contradictory requests through the editor when necessary.

Respond point by point with evidence

Use a consistent pattern: reviewer comment → response → specific change → manuscript location. Thank the reviewer without adding repetitive praise. State clearly when new analyses, controls or citations were added.

Illustrative response

Reviewer 2, Comment 3: “Please clarify how missing values were handled.”

Response: “Thank you for highlighting this omission. We added the missing-data decision rule and the percentage of missing observations to Methods (page 7, lines 142–154). We also added a sensitivity analysis in Supplementary Table S2. The revised results are consistent with the primary analysis.”

Disagree respectfully when the request is unsuitable

You do not have to accept every suggestion. Explain the scientific or practical reason when a request would compromise the design, introduce unsupported claims or require unavailable data. Offer an appropriate alternative, such as a limitation statement, sensitivity analysis or targeted clarification.

Avoid “the reviewer is wrong.” Instead, describe the methodological constraint, supporting evidence and exact revision made to help the reader.

Revise tables, methods and claims together

Reviewer comments often reveal cross-document inconsistencies. If analysis changes, review the abstract, results, tables, discussion and conclusion for knock-on edits. Remove obsolete claims, update numbers and check that new references actually support the relevant sentences.

  • Highlight changed text if the journal requests it.
  • Maintain separate clean and tracked versions where required.
  • Verify that every reviewer comment has a visible response.
  • Check that the manuscript and letter use the same terminology and values.

Follow publication ethics and editorial instructions

Do not invent analyses, fabricate reviewer responses, conceal meaningful limitations or promise work that was not done. Disclose conflicts and substantial changes as required by the journal. If a requested experiment is infeasible, discuss its limitation transparently.

For biomedical fields, consult the ICMJE recommendations and journal-specific policies. A revision letter should improve transparency rather than simply persuade the editor.

Use a pre-submission quality check

Ask a coauthor unfamiliar with the revisions to follow each response to the revised manuscript. Every “we have clarified” should point to actual text. Recheck anonymization, supplementary files, figure resolution, word limits and author approvals before submission.

Frequently asked questions

How should I answer a reviewer I disagree with?

Explain the evidence or methodological constraint calmly, respond to the underlying concern, and document any clarification or alternative analysis made.

Do I need to answer every reviewer comment?

Generally yes, using the journal’s instructions. If requests overlap, cross-reference a complete response rather than leaving a comment unanswered.

What is a good reviewer response format?

A numbered point-by-point document with the comment, author response, exact change and manuscript page/line references is usually easy to assess.

Further reading and standards

Official guidance can help you check requirements. Always follow your university, ethics committee and target journal’s current instructions.

Academic integrity: This educational guide provides general research information. Use it alongside your institution’s guidance and retain full responsibility for original research, analysis and submissions.

Need tailored research guidance?

Explore our related services or discuss your project requirements.

Explore relevant serviceContact ILM Research Solutions